More Than Pizza. It’s a Craft.

Every pizza we make is rooted in tradition, driven by passion, and crafted to bring people together.

Our Story

For Fidel, our founder, pizza is more than ingredients on dough — it’s a lifelong passion. Fidel’s journey with pizza began when he worked as a delivery driver on the weekends. What started as a side hustle became a fascination with ‘delicious.’ Papa Pizza Pie was founded, and more than 20 years later, we have a loyal following that grows every day. We’re just excited to see what the future holds!

Ingredients Matter

We believe you can taste the difference when ingredients are chosen with intention.

Locally Sourced Produce

Fresh vegetables from trusted regional farms

Artisan Cheeses


Carefully selected for flavor, melt, and balance

Slow-Fermented Dough

Prepared daily for better texture and digestibility

No Compromises


No artificial flavors or unnecessary additives

Crafted by hand. Fired with care.

Pizza For All

You should never feel left out at a pizza party, no matter what your dietary restrictions may be. Under Fidel’s leadership, our team uses the highest quality ingredients to craft pizzas for all palates. We fearlessly challenge the boundaries of what pizza can be, fine-tuning each recipe for maximum enjoyment. There’s a reason we already have two successful locations!

Loved by Our Community

Papa Pizza Pie
4.3
Based on 1313 reviews
powered by Yelp logo
Erika R.Erika R.
15:07 09 Nov 25
Decent neighborhood pizza. Toppings were generous, crust a little soft. Free breadsticks were tasty and definitely improved the meal. Good value for a quick...
Elijah I.Elijah I.
13:33 29 Sep 25
First time checking this spot out while in the area. The inside has a couple of small tables for seating -- simple setup, no restroom on-site, but it works...
Brent J.Brent J.
10:39 31 Aug 25
One of best pizza restaurants in Fullerton.Quality is always same and solid.Wings are good too.
js_loader

Masterpieces You Can Taste

We craft pizza with love and passion because we care about the people who eat it — we care about you. Average pizza simply isn’t something we do. Instead, we satisfy your unique taste and give you a reason to come back. Bring your family, bring your friends, or just bring yourself — our family can’t wait to welcome you.